Hello dear
Welcome To Pizzaiolo - East York
Welcome to Pizzaiolo - East York, a gem located at 2640 St Clair Ave E, where tradition meets flavor in delightful harmony. Known for their fresh dough made daily, Pizzaiolo offers an impressive assortment of pizzas, including gluten-free options and classic alternatives like the indulgent Godfather deep dish. Each bite showcases perfectly crisp crusts and vibrant toppings, celebrated by customers for their quality and taste. The friendly service, highlighted by proprietor Mustafa’s dedication to customer satisfaction, ensures a warm atmosphere that invites you to return. Whether it's a casual pickup or a family meal, Pizzaiolo surely delivers a memorable pizza experience.
About
Pizzaiolo - East York
Welcome to Pizzaiolo - East York, a delightful gem located at 2640 St Clair Ave E, East York, ON M4B 2S6, Canada. Nestled in a vibrant neighborhood, this pizza haven stands out not just for its delicious offerings but also for its commitment to customer satisfaction.
When you step into Pizzaiolo, you're met with a warm, welcoming atmosphere and friendly service that sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Customers rave about the diligent staff—like Santosh, who has earned enthusiastic shout-outs for making visits enjoyable.
The menu boasts a variety of meat pizzas, including the tantalizing Honey Heat and classic favorites like the Toni Pepperoni and Mafioso. For those seeking something heartier, the deep dish The Godfather promises a satisfying feast. Each pizza is crafted with a perfectly crisp crust and an abundance of fresh toppings, ensuring every bite is an explosion of flavor.
A standout review from Seiko Arafath highlights the freshness of the ingredients and the impeccable crust, making it clear that the pizza here is truly special. Another patron, Michelle Russell, shared her delightful experience with a credit offer from the owner, Mustafa, that underscores the high level of customer care at this location. It's rare to find such dedication to customer feedback, and it speaks volumes about the values at Pizzaiolo.
Despite the occasional hiccup, like slight mix-ups, patrons still return for the stellar taste that consistently outshines other chains. John L's nostalgic visit revealed that Pizzaiolo's pizza remains unparalleled, evoking fond memories of the past. Customers consistently mention the huge portion sizes, confirming that you'll leave satisfied.
In terms of beverages, San Pellegrino, Brio, and Smart Water complement your meal perfectly, rounding out the authentic Italian pizza experience.
Pizzaiolo - East York stands as a testament to what great pizza should be—delicious, fresh, and served with a smile. With ample street parking and a spacious interior, it’s an ideal spot for a casual meal or takeout. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and indulge in a slice of their mouthwatering offerings. You won't be disappointed!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I absolutely loved the pizza here! The crust was perfectly crisp, the toppings were fresh, and the service was super friendly. Shout out to Santosh! I will definitely be coming back! ”
“ UPDATE - March 16/23 Sunday evening I received a phone call from the owner letting me know that he wanted to make his customer happy and offered me a credit on my order. I mentioned that I would like to receive the pizzas on Thursday and to my surprise I received another followup phone call from the owner, Mustafa reminding about the pizzas. He took my order over the phone and I was there in about 25 minutes to pick up my order. This time I ordered the medium pepperoni tiny cup and large pepperoni and mushroom. It tasted really good. Their pepperoni tastes great and much better than the Pizza Pizza located right across the road from them. I do not usually provide a 5 star rating but Mustafa and this Pizziolo location deserved it because of their excellent customer service and great pizza. Thanks for making my evening and I will order again. Original post: I ordered two pizza, the first being the pick up medium pepperoni special for 10.99 and the next being the large two toppings with either dipping sauce or two drinks for 15.99. I picked up pizzas around 50 minutes after ordering. There was lots of parking on side of building. The front faces O'connor. When picking up there was a slight error in the medium pepperoni; I wanted the tiny cups but the person ordering provided the regular pepperoni. The pepperoni pizza tasted really good, great crust, sauce and pepperoni. It could have more cheese than it did. The rapini and sausage was not bad; I think I received too many stems of the rapini which were tougher when eating it. It also could of had more cheese on the pizza. I wanted to pay extra for goat cheese but the young lady on the phone who took the order said it was not an option. I have ordered from Pizzaiolo before for a company function and wanted to pick up for myself and family. I was not really impressed with the customer service and was slightly underwhelmed with the pizza. Unfortunately I won't be going out of my way to order again. ”
“ I haven't been to a Pizzaiolo in a minute. The location I used to love was Broadview n Queen until it closed up shop and went away. I loved that location. This was my first visit since then. This was just as good. The person behind the counter was very pleasant and congenial. She made the experience so much better. And the pizza was so so good. Just like how it used to be. I was even saying it to the person who I was eating with "how do the pizza here always tastes so much better then the other chains?" Cause all of the other chains are so blah sometimes. Anyways I am happy and will be returning for sure. ”
“ Ordered two large pizzas for pickup on a Sunday around noon. Staff here had no issues with my 1/2 tipping split pizzas. There's street parking infront of the restaurant. Staff are friendly and the pizza was delicious. ”
“ Pizza was ready on time, the right amount of everything, tasty and hot. Good crust. The whole Extra-Large vanished in no time and only 2 of us. This was a pickup so I could not give a 5 stars but the place is big so lots of room between tables which is nice in my opinion. This was my first time and will definitely go again. ”
“ Pizzaiolo never disappoints! The food is always fresh, delicious, and full of flavour. Their pizzas have the perfect balance of crispy crust, rich sauce, and high-quality toppings—whether you're into classic favourites or gourmet creations, there's something for everyone. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and always ready to help with great recommendations. You can tell they care about their customers and take pride in what they do. The service is fast and efficient, making it a great spot for a quick bite or a casual meal. Highly recommend Pizzaiolo if you're looking for top-notch pizza with fantastic service. Can’t wait to come back! ”
“ Best crust available locally. Generous toppings. Friendly people. This has become our “Go To” pizza joint. Whether it’s takeout or eat in the pizza’s always delicious. We have been many times for a slice and ordered out quite a few. By now we’ve just about sampled all the many styles available. The pizza is always made right with a nice brown bottom and plentiful toppings. We probably have 10-15 pizzerias within a couple of miles and this is the only one we now use. ”
“ I recently had the pleasure of trying this place and it definitely exceeded my expectations. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was welcoming and cozy, with friendly staff that made me feel right at home. The pizza itself was phenomenal — perfectly crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. The portions were generous, and I left feeling completely satisfied. Whether you’re a fan of classic toppings or adventurous combinations, there’s something for everyone here. I can’t wait to return for another slice — highly recommend! ”